Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Course : Universality and Cosmopolitanism vs. Locality

LEPE2 - Miltiadis Vantsos, Kaveh Dastooreh, Sucharita Sen, Kostas Koukouzelis

Course Units

XI. Human rights and the 'margin of appreciation' in the European Court of HR

Unit overview

The 'margin of appreciatiion' is a contested concept in human rights law. It is a judicial doctrine that allows national authorities a degree of flexibility and discretion when interpreting and applying human rights obligations at the local level. The concept has been introduced by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) and has attracted criticisms for cultural relativism. First of all, we shall discuss in philosophical terms the potential conflict between human rights' universal validity and its criticism. Second, we shall explain the concept of the 'margin of appreciation' and its pros and cons regarding EU law. A contrast with UN Human Rights Committee's diverging approach will be finally presented briefly.

Keywords

ethics; morality; law; consequentialism; deontology; relativism; EU law; normative ethics

Required readings

Complementary readings