Course : Universality and Cosmopolitanism vs. Locality
LEPE2 - Miltiadis Vantsos, Kaveh Dastooreh, Sucharita Sen, Kostas Koukouzelis
-
Display all units
-
I. Debates on Universal Rights: Key issues in Human Rights and the idea of Global Justice
-
II. Multiculturalism and its Challenges: The Ethical Grounds for Multicultural Citizenship
-
III. Enlightenment Universalism vs Post-colonialism: Diverging Views
-
IV. The significance of local and global factors in ethical decision-making
-
V. Is a universal and ecumenical ethics feasible for major issues of global concern?
-
VI. The case of bioethics: points of convergence
-
VII. The case of bioethics: points of divergence
-
VIII. The case of ecological ethics: points of convergence
-
IX. The case of ecological ethics: points of divergence
-
X. The phenomenon of globalization: benefits and risks
-
XI. Human rights and the 'margin of appreciation' in the European Court of HR
-
XII. From theory to the practice of HR: Religious symbols, climate change and cosmopolitanism
-
I. Debates on Universal Rights: Key issues in Human Rights and the idea of Global Justice
XI. Human rights and the 'margin of appreciation' in the European Court of HR

Unit overview
The 'margin of appreciatiion' is a contested concept in human rights law. It is a judicial doctrine that allows national authorities a degree of flexibility and discretion when interpreting and applying human rights obligations at the local level. The concept has been introduced by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) and has attracted criticisms for cultural relativism. First of all, we shall discuss in philosophical terms the potential conflict between human rights' universal validity and its criticism. Second, we shall explain the concept of the 'margin of appreciation' and its pros and cons regarding EU law. A contrast with UN Human Rights Committee's diverging approach will be finally presented briefly.
Keywords
ethics; morality; law; consequentialism; deontology; relativism; EU law; normative ethics
Required readings
- Nickel, James. "Human Rights." The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2026 Edition). Edited by Edward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman. https://plato.stanford.edu/cgi-bin/encyclopedia/archinfo.cgi?entry=rights-human.
Complementary readings
- Griffin, James. 'The Relativity and Ethnocentricity of Human Rights." In R. Cruft, S.M. Liao, and M. Renzo (eds.), The Philosophical Foundations of Human Rights, 555-569. Oxford University Press, 2015. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199238781.003.0008.
- Benvenisti, Eyal. "Margin of Appreciation, Consensus, and Universal Standards." New York University Journal of International Law & Politics 31 (1999): 843-854. https://access.heinonline.com/HOL/P?h=hein.journals/nyuilp31&i=851.