Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Course : Authority and Institutional Discourse

LEPC3 - Charalambos Tsekeris, Nikos Erinakis, Spiros Tegos, Despina Vertzagia, Ayelet Shavit

Course Units

VIII. Liberalism and Institutional Discourse: Religious Toleration, Freedom of Conscience, and Political Authority

Unit overview

This unit examines the emergence of liberal political thought through the relationship between institutional authority, religious toleration, and freedom of conscience. It explores how early modern political philosophy reconsidered the foundations and limits of political and religious authority, challenging established forms of institutional control over individual belief, philosophical inquiry, and public expression.Particular attention is devoted to the transformation of the relationship between political sovereignty and religious authority in the writings of Thomas Hobbes, Benedict de Spinoza, and John Locke. The unit investigates how competing conceptions of sovereignty, natural right, and individual freedom contributed to the development of new arguments concerning the legitimate scope of institutional power and the distinction between public authority and private conviction. Drawing on Spinoza's Theological-Political Treatise, the discussion examines the relationship between freedom of philosophizing (libertas philosophandi), religious authority, and the preservation of political order. Spinoza's defence of freedom of thought and expression is considered in relation to the institutional regulation of religious doctrines and the political implications of theological disagreement. The unit subsequently explores Locke's defence of religious toleration, focusing on his distinction between the responsibilities of civil government and the purposes of religious associations, as well as the historical and philosophical limitations of his conception of toleration. The discussion further considers the relationship between liberalism and institutional discourse, asking how political institutions establish the boundaries of legitimate public expression while simultaneously claiming to protect individual liberty. Particular emphasis is placed on the tension between the authority of the state to maintain civil peace and the freedom of individuals to question prevailing religious, moral, and political doctrines. Ultimately, the unit approaches religious toleration not merely as a moral virtue or a principle of peaceful coexistence, but as a fundamental problem of political philosophy concerning the legitimacy, scope, and limitations of institutional authority. It invites students to consider whether liberal political institutions can remain neutral toward competing conceptions of truth and how the protection of freedom of conscience transforms the relationship between political power and public discourse.

 

Keywords

liberalism; institutional discourse; religious toleration; freedom of conscience; freedom of thought; freedom of expression; political authority; religious authority; sovereignty; institutional legitimacy; natural rights; church and state; religious pluralism; institutional neutrality; libertas philosophandi; public discourse

 

Required readings

  • Spinoza, Benedict de. Theological-Political Treatise. Edited by Jonathan Israel. Translated by Michael Silverthorne and Jonathan Israel. Cambridge University Press, 2007. Chapters 19–20.

  • Locke, John. A Letter Concerning Toleration. Translated by William Popple, 1689.

Complementary readings

  • Hobbes, Thomas. Leviathan. Edited by Richard Tuck. Cambridge University Press, 1996. Chapters 16–18 and 21.

  • Mendus, Susan. Toleration and the Limits of Liberalism.Humanities Press International, 1989.